Protein Shakes Vs Protein Powder [4 Pros & Cons + Nutrition]

In this blog post, a detailed comparison is made between “Protein shakes vs protein powder”. Protein shakes and protein powder are both good sources of protein. Protein shake has some extra nutrient that is not in protein powder.

But protein shakes are quite expensive as compared to protein powder. We discussed in detail the advantages and disadvantages of protein shakes and protein powder and gave you the nutritional values of both.

After reading this you can easily choose a good one for you.

Protein Shakes Vs Protein Powder

Protein shakes and protein powder are the two supplements that provide you with a higher quantity of protein. I categorized protein shakes into two types. A homemade protein shake and a pre-made protein shake.

A homemade protein shake is made by adding protein powder with milk, some fresh fruits, nuts, and other ingredients. It is rich in protein and contains good amounts of other nutrients. This homemade protein shake is better than protein powder.

But here in this blog post, we will do a comparison between pre-made protein shakes and protein powder. Both products are processed through different physical and chemical processes, and both are factory-made.

Difference Between Pre-Made Protein Shakes and Protein Powder?

A protein shake is a ready-made beverage that is a convenient source of protein. Many brands sell their protein shakes in single-serving bottles or cotton which contains 8-10 bottles.

Protein shakes contain a high content of protein having both whey and casein protein. They contain a good number of vitamins and minerals (contain a high amount of fiber and calcium). The quantity of carbs and fat in protein shakes is relatively low. Most brands use zero-calorie sweeteners (like sucralose and acesulfame) to maintain low-calorie content.

On the other hand, protein powder is available in dry and solid form. You can get protein powder either in whey, casein, or soy form. You can also get a combo of these proteins in a single protein powder.

Protein powders are available in different flavors to improve their taste. They add natural sweeteners to maintain the taste. Protein powders can be added to water and milk to make a shake. It can also be added to food like oatmeal, yogurt, or pancakes to increase protein content.

Protein Shakes VS Protein Powder In Term Of Nutrition

In terms of nutrition content, protein shakes have a little advantage because they contain a good amount of protein premier protein shakes give you 30g of protein per serving but are also rich in vitamins and minerals.

It contains 3 to 4 grams of fiber and has a good amount of calcium, magnesium, and phosphorous. Although the nutrition values vary with brand but if you buy a good shake of any brand, you can get the above number of nutrition values.

Another rich source of protein is protein powder. It provides you 25g of protein per scoop depending on the brand. But mostly you can get around to that number. But protein powder lacks other nutrients like fiber, fat, and other vitamins and minerals.

Protein Shakes Vs Protein Powder In Terms of Cost

Protein shakes provide a high content of protein with extra nutrients. In terms of cost, it is expensive as compared to protein powder. But you can adjust it if you want more nutrients. You do not need to prepare your shake. You can grab it with yourself in the gym or at work and enjoy it.

Protein powder, on the other hand, is versatile and it can be used in a variety of ways. You can use it in a homemade protein shake or in your other foods. It is less expensive than a protein shake. Yes, you are right, it gives you only protein, not other nutrients. But if you add it with other foods like oatmeal or fresh fruit and milk you can get other nutrients too.

Processed Behind Their Manufacturing

Protein shakes are made by blending or mixing different ingredients with water or milk. The ingredients include water, milk protein concentrate, Calcium caseinate, natural and artificial flavor, vitamins, and preservatives (to increase their life). These ingredients are blended until you get a tasty and smooth shake.

On the other hand, protein powder is made by extracting protein from animal or plant-based sources like milk, eggs, peas, meat, or other sources. Then different techniques are used to purify the protein which is then dried to get protein powder.

Also Read: Protein Pancakes vs Protein Shake.

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Protein Shakes

Protein shakes have a lot of advantages and disadvantages which are given below.

Advantages Of Protein Shakes

1. Protein shakes are in low calories hence they help in weight management.

2. Protein shakes are readymade and more convenient than protein powder. You can take it with you.

3. The biggest benefit is that it contributes a good amount of protein to your daily protein consumption.

4. It contains a variety of nutrients like protein, vitamins, and minerals.

Disadvantages Of Protein Shakes

1. Protein shakes cost so much more than other meals.

2. Some protein shakes contain high sugar content which increases the risk of diabetes.

3. If you are using an average protein shake it tastes chalky. This is because the quality of the ingredients is not good.

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Protein Powder

Protein powder has a number of advantages and disadvantages which are listed below.

Advantages Of Protein Powder

1. Protein powder contains high quality and quantity protein. It is available in different flavors.

2. It increases your protein intake and is beneficial for muscle growth and recovery.

3. It is low in calories and is helpful in weight management.

4. It can be used with other foods you can make a protein shake by using it with milk or water. You can also use it with pancakes and oatmeal.

Disadvantages Of Protein Powder

1. While protein powder contains good amounts of protein, it often lacks other nutrients like vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients found in foods.

2. Artificial sweeteners used in protein powder may cause digestive issues.

3. Some protein powders have high sugar content which may cause many health issues.

Nutrient Values Of Protein Shakes And Protein Powder

Protein shakes and protein powder are both rich in protein. The other nutrients which are present in these two are given below.

ProductProteinFiberCarbsFatsCalories ContentCalciumPrice Per Serving
Protein Shake24-30g3g4-8g2-5g140-170 kcal500-600 mg$2-2.5
Protein Powder20-30g1%0-8g0-2g100-130 kcal100-150




The summary of the blog post “Protein shakes vs protein powder”. We will discuss the nutritional values and cost of both the protein shakes and protein powder. After that, we discuss the pros and cons of both so that you can easily pick one from them.

I suggested that if you can make different food then choose protein powder. You can add it to the food and get extra benefits of protein with other nutrients. If you want to increase protein intake without making foods, then go with protein shakes. It provides you with protein with extra nutrients.

1 thought on “Protein Shakes Vs Protein Powder [4 Pros & Cons + Nutrition]”

  1. Pingback: Whey Protein Vs Vegan Protein? Which is Best For You - My Protein World

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *